Home

Register |  Forgot Password
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Introduction
    • Policy
    • Feeds
  • Blog
    • Feed
  • Tidbits
    • Feed
  • News
    • Bangladesh
    • India
    • Nepal
    • Pakistan
    • Sri Lanka
    • Diaspora
    • Other

Review: Unaccustomed Earth

By: khargosh on 19 May 2008

Jhumpa Lahiri's first book, The Interpreter of Maladies, came out when I was in college. I didn't have many desi friends at the time, ad I was skeptical when my non-desi friends raved about the book and insisted that I try to read it. The title and the cover made me skeptical - I was sure that the stories would be full of weeping women in saris lamenting the lack of romance in their lives while the scent of frying cardamom hung heavy in the air. And although there were some saris, and there was more than a little bit of cardamom, there was also something else, something I devoured hungrily and eagerly: there, on the page, was my life. I am not Bengali. My father is not a professor from New England. We do not eat fish. But in some inexplicable way, the characters on the page might as well have been members of my family, both real and adopted, here in the United States. It was the first time I had seen myself in a book, and I sat in the library and read the whole thing in one sitting.

When The Namesake came out, I was pretty sure that it would be annoying at best, and cloying at worst. I heard about the male narrator and suspected that the voice that worked so well in Lahiri's short stories would devolve into self-pitying nonsense in a novel. Instead, once again, I found myself and my family between the pages, and once again, I read the whole thing in one sitting.

Last night, I started Unaccustomed Earth with the same trepidation with which I had approached Lahiri's other books. Would it be full of whiny stories about how awful it is to be an immigrant? Would there be cable knit sweaters and chicken curry and all of the other classically Lahiri elements that, in most other work, would be irritating beyond redemption? Would I read it and think that it deserved its place at the top of the best seller list?

As predicted, I picked up the book at 6 p.m. and went to bed after finishing it at 2 a.m. Also as predicted, I loved it, despite my initial doubts.

As much as it pains this contrary khargosh to go with the status quo, Unaccustomed Earth is, in fact, brilliant. Lahiri's language is Hemingwayesque: it is lyrical but spare, and every carefully chosen detail lends meaning and substance to the masterfully rendered plots. Although the stories are populated with Bengali immigrants, they are not written to capture some imaginary, sweeping immigrant experience. Instead, they are about very real, very universal human experiences, such as the evolution of marriage, the loss of family, the pain of watching a daughter or brother or parent suffer. Elements of South Asian culture are used to advance each story - in one story, a character's inauspicious loss of a gold bangle foreshadows a tragic event; in another, a string of phone call from Bengali suitors provide comic relief.

I'm not sure what it is about Lahiri that reminds me of myself and my family, but I found myself frequently pausing on various brilliant turns of phrase that could have substituted the names of cousins and siblings and parents of mine without losing any meaning. I don't know if this is because I am Indian; I think it is probably because I am human, and Lahiri has such a brilliant eye for the tragedy that undergirds monotony. The fact that there are cultural details that I can actually relate to is a bonus, rather than a reason why.

One last note - to me, this book felt much warmer than her others. Although none of the stories are particularly cheerful, and none have indisputably happy endings, her characters forgive each other in ways they have not necessarily in previous books. There is something cautiously hopeful about the collection, a quality that was missing from her other books, in which the characters seemed to travel long distances just to relate to their family and themselves. Perhaps this is a result of Lahiri's own journey into marriage, motherhood, and maturity. Perhaps, like me, Lahiri finds that as she grows older, her culture and her family are slowly reconciling themselves, and that the moments of alienation and confusion derived from living between two cultures are becoming more uncommon and less desperate. Whatever the reason, I put the book down feeling substantially less hollow than I usually do after my now ritual marathon-Lahiri sessions. My sadness was tempered with anticipation, as though I had just examined possible a map of my own future, and had decided that even if it didn't match the glossy dreams of my childhood, it would be enough.

  • khargosh's blog
  • Login or register to post comments
  • Share this
1 | neetu (not verified) | 19 May 2008 at 6:22 pm:

I'm glad to hear that the new book is lovely. I go through the same things with Lahiri's writing-- initial dread and then unbridled enthusiasm. I'm not sure what sparks the initial dread..maybe the fact that the topic of immigration is so tired and overplayed in the popular media. You forget how wonderful honest treatment of the subject matter can be.

I, also, loved the movie "The Namesake"- I thought Mira Nair did an amazing job with the material.

It's funny, though, as someone whose family is marwadi, lahiri's bengali world is ostensibly quite different from mine...and every once in a while, I encouter something that her characters do that feels really different from anything that my family would do (eat meat, drink alcohol)...but yet there is a familiarity, and a sense of home in her writing.

  • Login or register to post comments
2 | Amrutha Bushan (not verified) | 27 May 2008 at 5:24 pm:

yay to another Lahiri fan! :)

  • Login or register to post comments
3 | Bq (not verified) | 08 Jun 2008 at 8:54 pm:

I'm bengali-American and the world she creates seems somewhat alien to me, apart from superficial similarities (food, clothes, tacky carpeting).

  • Login or register to post comments
4 | Amardeep (not verified) | 23 May 2008 at 9:02 pm:

Hey, terrific review.

I have much the same reaction to Lahiri -- reading her is kind of an involuntary compulsion once I've picked up the book. I gather I am closer to her age than you are (her first book came out when I was already well into graduate school), so in fact many of the experiences she's talking about in this latest book (though it's fatherhood instead of motherhood in my case)
resemble my own.

  • Login or register to post comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Tags

Afghanistan Bangladesh civilians diaspora gosl human rights imperialism India internally displaced people journalism ltte military nepal obama pakistan politics refugees South Asia sri lanka sri lanka civil war tamil nadu United Nations violence war war crimes
more tags
Technorati Profile